The Quantity or Quality of Discipleship
|
I was talking to my father in law (Director of Missions for a Southern Baptist Regional Association) awhile back about his missionary trip to Romania. He was excited to tell me how many baptisms they conducted. This was just one instance. But I started to notice that the emphasis for many conservatives is almost always on the number, or frequency, of baptisms. What I seldom hear people talk about is the quality and depth of those many individual commitments to follow in Jesus’ name. Just today there were dire predictions commented on by Ed Stetzer, the well-known Lifeway statistician, blogger and evangelist, which said that the Southern Baptist Convention could decline by 50% over the few decades. The focus is almost always on the numbers—how many, not how well equipped to walk in the way of Jesus. Recently I read an intriguing article at Slate magazine. It was written by a Brown University student that had taken a semester off and enrolled in Liberty University. He went undercover as a way to learn about the conservative evangelical Christian subculture. You can read the rest by following the link. What most interests me about the article are the descriptions of the students evangelizing attempts during spring break in Daytona Beach, Florida. Similar to what I’ve noted above, these students’ attempts at evangelizing basically focused on the number of people approached on the street and saved that day. There was very little concern for developing any kind of long term relationship or bonds of Christian community. It was all about number; none about quality. Whatever the emerging Christian movement moves toward, I think that it is imperative to not move in this direction. A strong community of followers and committed individual believers are created and sustained over time through relationships, through building up one another. While at some level the number of followers is important, I argue that the quality of discipleship is far more important. |
Comments
Re: The Quantity or Quality of Discipleship
Good thought-provoking comments as usual, Jacob!
This is a rather lazy response, but I would argue that from a biblical point of view ‘evangelism’ is essentially the proclamation of what God has done or is doing or is about to do – historically – for the sake of his people. When Israel or the nations hear that proclamation, they sometimes believe that this genuinely is the case, that the proclamation can be trusted, and act accordingly. It seems to me that this perspective allows us to detach ourselves somewhat from the personal evangelism methodology, whether we put the emphasis on the quantity or the quality of conversion. It is not that the personal dimension is unimportant – there would be no wood without the trees. But evangelism is, in effect and in the first place, a public and political announcement. The question we need to ask today is: What is God now doing with regard to the existence of his people in the world? And what are the ramifications of that right down to the personal level? This is a contextualized evangelism, not a generic proposition of personal salvation. See also: Evangelism before and after Christendom.
Re: The Quantity or Quality of Discipleship
Having spent my teenage years in a Baptist church in Romania, I can tell you that looking back I am becoming really nauseous remembering the Evangelical American or Western push on Romanians (as far as conversion goes). There is a complete disconnect from reality. Most Romanians are already “Christians” - in an Eastern context. They may not be practicing as far as Westerners are concerned, and they may not be manifesting the individualistic man-Christ relationships which Evangelicals claim that identify one as a Christian.
So when it comes down to numbers, it mostly “the numbers of those who worship, believe and pray like we do.” The Eastern Orthodox Christians who do indeed pray to the same God, light candles and participate in a different liturgical worship do not count as Christians as far as the evangelicals are concerned. Unless you worship, pray and live in a western context, you are not one of “us” - that is the general attitude - I know because I grew up and lived in that environment for quite a while.
Re: The Quantity or Quality of Discipleship
I totally agree with you. Its a modern sales method. Evangelism as we have known it in the 20th century is an invention of evangelical ‘ideology’ (I use that word carefully and deliberately) … combined with sales techniques. Jesus condemned the Pharisees for traveling across land and sea to make converts … and then failing to teach them to incarnate the values of the KoG. We are not told to evangelize, we are told to love and serve, and provoke people to become disciplined and committed students of the life and teachings of Jesus.
We keep getting substandard results because keep using substandard and non-biblical methods with the wrong motivation. Any time there is subtle pressure to ‘convert’ someone, you can be gauaranteed you are dealing with an ideology, beit political or religious, rather than genuine ‘Jesus-style’ faith …