A while back I read a short article at Crosswalk.com, which was written by John Piper and entitled: “Making room for atheism.”
Piper is concerned with the question:
So how do we express a passion for God’s supremacy in a pluralistic world where most people do not recognize God as an important part of their lives, let alone an important part of government or education or business or industry or art or recreation or entertainment?
He lists five ways that “We express a passion for the supremacy of God.” I’m most interested in discussing number five. He says:
5) by making clear that God himself is the foundation for our commitment to a pluralistic democratic order-not because pluralism is his ultimate ideal, but because in a fallen world, legal coercion will not produce the kingdom of God. Christians agree to make room for non-Christian faiths (including naturalistic, materialistic faiths), not because commitment to God’s supremacy is unimportant, but because it must be voluntary, or it is worthless. We have a God-centered ground for making room for atheism. "If my kingship were of this world, my servants would fight" (John 18:36). The fact that God establishes his kingdom through the supernatural miracle of faith, not firearms, means that Christians in this age will not endorse coercive governments-Christian or secular.
Laudably, Piper is wary of governmental coercion. He rightly says that governments can’t make someone have faith in God. Amen to that!
But the government represents only one level of compulsion. Even more significant, the family unit can often function as another level of compulsion, especially for children and teenagers. Parents may compel their children to go to church and to worship God. Granted, most parents don’t use “firearms,” but they do use other means of force and threat, from with holding weekly allowances to physical punishment to the fear of damnation and everlasting hell.
In Matthew 19:14, Jesus said: "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these."
Look closely, Jesus says let “the little children come to me.” He does not say compel them to come to me. He doesn’t say make your unruly teenagers sit through the church service. Yet some of us do. And what’s worse, we do it in the name of the Lord.
Is it legitimate to compel your children to go to church? Is family-level coercion in line with Jesus exhortation to let “children com to me”? Does this kind of compulsion have negative effects on young people and their understanding of church and God? Does it do more harm than good? Does it do more good than harm?


Re: Forcing Kids and Teenagers to Attend Church
I can say from experience do not force your children to go to church if they really don’t want to. Expose them to it at a young age, but if as they grow they honestly have no interest in it whatsoever; there is no sense in forcing them to go. I realize, however, some parents have no choice but to bring their kids to church; if the parent is going, the child must go also because he can’t be left at home alone.
I was raised being told “You need to go to church” (why?) and I was sometimes forced, but I remained relatively “lukewarm” for Jesus and the gospel regardless of how much I attended church. I can tell you when I did go to church I usually did not like the people, I was extremely bored, could not pay attention to the sermon, and definitely did not feel any closer to God (if not the opposite). Eventually my parents gave up on me.
I know parents who forced their children go to church every week and now that they are grown up and in college they can care less about Christianity. For example, one mother who recently divorced her alcoholic husband and decided she needed to return to church brought her daughter to a church dinner I was attending. Some lady asked if her daughter would help with the children in another room. Apparently the girl was helping blow up balloons for the little kids. Some guy (who is way too pushy) came up to his mother and said something like, “You should see your daughter, she is blowing up balloons and really enjoying herself!” By the time the service was about to end, and the girl was about to come back into the main room, that same guy said, “You couldn’t get her in here but now that it is time to leave I bet she won’t want to.” Ironically, the girl walks up to her mother right at the moment and says as if she has been in jail, “Mom, can we please go!” The man who should have realized he had just eaten his words foolishly comments, “Come on, you know you had fun!” Well, I can just imagine that this girl was more put off from Christianity and church before she even was introduced to it.
I believe there is a certain age for each child when he realizes what Christianity and church really means. Some never do. Some do and ignore the significance of it all and go on with their lives living in the bondage of sin. Some people expect this specific age to be early, when almost always it is in fact not. People expect their kids to be “born again” at the age of ten when these kids don’t even know what the heck “born again” means and how significant it really is. They instruct these kids in Sunday school that Jesus is “Lord,” “Savior,” “God’s son,” and so on, but some of these kids are not yet old enough to know what those titles mean and imply. Sure, Jesus died on the cross and rose from the dead, a kid might repeat, but what does that mean for the world? Some kids might not even know what death is let alone resurrection!
I later, of my own will, developed a serious interest in Jesus and the gospel. Now I go to church willing more than once a week. In fact, I was complaining the other day there are not enough church services during the week in my area. Sometimes my mother says, “I should have made you go to church more often.” And I comment, “I’m glad you didn’t.”
While I think it is important to introduce our kids to the gospel and a Christian community, I also think it is almost vital we do not force them to go to church once they reach the age they realize they truly are not interested. I mean, kids are kids. Nothing personal to Jesus, but church is not a fun place for a kid who wants to be outside running around or at home playing with his toys, and when adults try to make it fun for children, it usually ends up worse; never have I seen them think to ask what the children would enjoy. Church is not a place of fellowship in a renewed, Spirit-filled community devoted to the Lord Jesus for a child; church is a boring place where everyone smiles at you because you are young, some old guy stands at the pulpit and blabs on about some nonsense you cannot understand or even want to understand, and where you have to go to go every week (on the weekend no less!), sit still, and do nothing for an hour.
Teenagers are another story and it honestly depends on each individual. In High School, I began realizing the significance of Christianity and fellowship. But then again, I was a pretty motivated student who took English classes serious; once I began taking literature seriously, the Bible made much more sense. On the other hand, other, I would say, typical teenagers do not fully appreciate their schoolwork let alone church. Some, as I did, have that one passion in High School, like music, or English, but most never learn about Christianity from those passions. Most teenagers are very social; they are thinking about their friends and the opposite sex. The weekend for the average teenager is an escape from the labors of school, a time to go hang out with friends, and most of all, a time to sleep in! Most teenagers do not want to wake up for church on Sunday when they could be doing something better with that time.
Some people try to get teenagers involved with youth groups, but most teenagers (myself included) do not want any part with that. They want to hang out with their own friends, not some people they do not know. Plus, I imagine there is a cliché, stereotypical image engrained in the teenager mind of the way Christian teenagers act, the ones who attend those young groups.
Then also, there is the weirdness of some churches. For example, my one friend has a chronic illness, and his parents keep trying to talk him into going to church for prayer. He refuses. Why? Because the whole thing freaks him out. Most prayer services, especially charismatic services, involves speaking in tongues, laying on of hands, more of those smiling, drunk looking people we have grown to fear from our childhood. No teenager wants some stranger touching him, smiling at him, and speaking in tongues at him, myself included. So if you are trying to get your teenager to go to a charismatic church, you have the “weirdness-factor” to consider.
Of course, I do not have children myself, and I imagine my opinion is somewhat biased because it is based on my own past expierences. I’d be interested to hear what a parent says.
Re: Forcing Kids and Teenagers to Attend Church
Thanks. Your comments are thoughtful and they show well your experiences.
I’m glad you decided to comment. I think many folks are hesitant to talk about family-level coercion when it comes to church. But it is something worthwhile to talk about, I think.
And you make a great point: we should ask kids what they want and not just assume we know what they want. We need to seriously consider their words and not just speak at them or for them.
Re: Forcing Kids and Teenagers to Attend Church
Let me elaborate on that point and another point.
Churches are typically controlled by adults, usually adults in their 40s. Realizing most children are unhappy going to church if they are forced, and teenagers could care less and usually are not forced, these adults try to make their services more entertaining to these crowds based on their image of “cool.” The result is usually something artificial, fake, and really quite pathetic. For example, one day some lady (smiling, as if I were two years old) came up to me in church, assuming I am much younger than I am, and said something like, “We’re having a halloween party , you should come! We’re gonna have candy. And we got the good stuff!” It totally surprised me. I didn’t know what to say. I understand she was just trying to be nice, but the average teenager does not think that way. The average teenager would be completely put off, and regardless, would not be interested in a church halloween party in the first place. Well, that situation was worth it, because my friend Timothy (who is in his 30s) got to witness the look on my face and started laughing. On the other hand, maybe my views of how the church works and what church members are trying to do is cliché and an example of relatively new I am to church (in willingness).
Regardless of my bias, the reality is that the church needs to involve the crowds they are trying to appeal to for decision making. Brian Mclaren kind of picks up on this point for David Loveless to respond at a Willow Creek Arts Conference of 2007:
The suggestion is interesting, but I wonder how the differences between Jewish and American culture would affect the seriousness of young-peoples’ suggestions, assuming they would be motivated to make suggestionS in the first place. Definitely something to consider.
On the other hand, I hate how church and the gospel is sometimes turned into a product, something that needs better advertisement plans to bring in the money (i.e. convert the souls). I wonder how we can avoid that.
The next point I would like to pick up on is important as well. Too often church going is equated with being a Christian. Some people have the view that if you go to church you are a Christian and if you do not go to church you are not a Christian. This is a false dichotomy. When I began devoting myself to Jesus, took a serious interest in studying the Bible as a commitment to God, and realized I needed a change of lifestyle (though my lifestyle was almost the same before and after these realizations), I did not start going to church until recently (so that was about two years). This was mostly because I was not sure what church sould serve my cup of tea and I was not ready to find out. However, my lack of going to church did not rule out my loyality to God and his son Jesus. The same can be said of the vice versa. Some people force themselves into the pew every Sunday but could care less about God the rest of the time. For example, Bart Ehrman made a comment in Misquoting Jesus something like this: “We went to church on Sunday to make up for what we did on Saturday.” Another example includes some of my fellow students who go to church on Sunday (probably forced) but do not live the life-style. It seems Christainity is almost mythic to some of my peers (and even adults), something you cannot hope to touch, something that has no basis in history, but something you believe because it is your “faith,” faith you express only once a week.
I think church needs to be thought of less as the place you go and should go, as if it were a building, and more of (as it is in the Bible) a community that is not bound to one building. If your kids won’t go church, get involved with them at home (e.g. if your kids are not completely put off by it, have a family Bible study every once and a while, or something like that).
I’m sure there are ways to bring the church to our children rather than bring our children to the church, but I’m dry on ideas of how that would work.
Re: Forcing Kids and Teenagers to Attend Church
Double posted by mistake.