Homosexuality vs. Gay People
Homosexuality vs. Gay People
sbryan said:
in order to conclude that Paul doesn’t like gay people
(2) Actually, I think the first step would be for you to justify not distinguishing between homosexual practice and gay people. Paul, as far as I can tell, doesn’t say anything about the relevance of one’s sexual orientation as a defining characteristic of who that person IS. He seems more inclined to discuss generalized homosexual behavior as one-among-many evidences that the image-bearing purpose of humanity is marred and that creation has been flawed/damaged and in need of serious remedy. I don’t think anyone on this forum is seriously proposing that either God or Paul has anything but the deepest love and hope for new creation in all of humanity, whether practicing homosexual or not.
(1) The quote from the symposium was specifically in reference to the argument that is often heard that people in Paul’s world were simply unaware of the possibility of the kind of committed monogamous homosexual relationship that we now see in our cultural situation, so therefore Paul can’t be presumed to have said anything about it. Well, Plato shows that this is simply not the case. Such relationships were known to exist. It was not intended to prove a position on the issue, just meant to demonstrate that the data for one defense is in fact inaccurate.
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: gmanon (25/01/2010 - 22:36)
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: arevans74 (21/01/2010 - 17:06)
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: Tammy Ricks (10/12/2009 - 19:19)
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: joeAnne (10/01/2009 - 15:32)
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: Tiara79 (29/11/2009 - 07:46)
- Re: A committed monogamous homosexual versus a slave owner By: Cilionelle (25/03/2006 - 19:03)
- Taking experience seriously By: Lawrence (30/06/2005 - 23:21)
- Re: Taking experience seriously By: Cilionelle (25/03/2006 - 19:11)
- Inconsistency of the condemnation of homosexuality By: paulhartigan (01/07/2005 - 09:29)
- Notwithstanding, the Word of God remains the same By: Soldier3001 (05/07/2005 - 16:45)
- I'm not ignoring your recent By: Ivan Latham (03/04/2005 - 05:04)
- Bait and switch, red herring By: Soldier3001 (29/06/2005 - 21:09)
- ahhh, sweet grey By: mars-hill (30/06/2005 - 03:15)
- Bait and switch, red herring By: Soldier3001 (29/06/2005 - 21:09)
- Even worse, they're re-crucifying Christ By: (02/04/2005 - 02:04)
- Adam and Eve By: paynedaniel (29/06/2005 - 05:37)
- I am astounded at the level o By: sbryan (02/04/2005 - 02:36)
- I doubt Ivan and SBryan By: erlenmeyer71 (02/04/2005 - 03:43)
- I agree. I hope this doesn't By: sbryan (02/04/2005 - 04:39)
- I doubt Ivan and SBryan By: erlenmeyer71 (02/04/2005 - 03:43)
- A wedge By: Spiritboi (12/03/2005 - 23:33)
- sexual idolatry By: 1beggar (13/03/2005 - 01:27)
- "homosexual relationships" By: paynedaniel (29/06/2005 - 04:28)
- sexual idolatry By: guest (27/03/2005 - 19:18)
- the place of homosexuality in the faith By: guest (28/03/2005 - 14:44)
- sexual idolatry By: 1beggar (13/03/2005 - 01:27)
- Slavery and Self Control. By: Alario (08/03/2005 - 02:19)
- Gays are not madder or badder than anybody else By: paulhartigan (25/03/2005 - 06:38)
- Sodomising the Body of Christ By: (01/04/2005 - 17:37)
- The word "Sodom" By: paynedaniel (29/06/2005 - 04:24)
- Bringing it down a notch By: erlenmeyer71 (01/04/2005 - 22:56)
- Prostitution = Homosexuality? I'm not convinced. By: sbryan (02/04/2005 - 01:17)
- A Hateful Subject Line By: sbryan (01/04/2005 - 17:50)
- Full disclosure By: erlenmeyer71 (28/03/2005 - 16:13)
- Sodomising the Body of Christ By: (01/04/2005 - 17:37)
- "What do the scriptures say?" By: sbryan (08/03/2005 - 07:04)
- Theology of Love By: asserhed (08/03/2005 - 10:07)
- Gays are not madder or badder than anybody else By: paulhartigan (25/03/2005 - 06:38)
- Paul, homosexuality and slavery By: peter wilkinson (07/03/2005 - 10:46)
- Gays in the congregation By: erlenmeyer71 (08/03/2005 - 17:26)
- Second Temple Homosexuality? By: ericboehmer (08/03/2005 - 17:09)
- Plato? By: lancebrisbois (28/06/2006 - 04:11)
- Where "from Plato" do we see By: sbryan (09/03/2005 - 20:04)
- Plato's Symposium By: ericboehmer (09/03/2005 - 20:18)
- Contrary to the Symposium Quote By: Eonasdan (05/08/2005 - 20:36)
- Now, in order to conclude tha By: sbryan (10/03/2005 - 00:54)
- Homosexuality vs. Gay People By: ericboehmer (10/03/2005 - 01:21)
- Plato's Symposium By: ericboehmer (09/03/2005 - 20:18)
- The problem of 'versus' By: asserhed (07/03/2005 - 10:40)
- Paul and social justice By: erlenmeyer71 (06/03/2005 - 23:47)
- Paul spoke from his matrix By: kiwimac (29/06/2005 - 09:02)

Contradictions in the Gospels: Problems or Opportunities?
Day One: A Sir Toby's Creation Myth
A Generous Orthdoxy - Brian McLaren
The Lost World of Genesis One - John H. Walton